Local Property Management You Can Count On
TriStar Realty, LLC is a locally owned and operated full-service property management company based in Greeley, Colorado. We specialize in residential and commercial property management across Northern Colorado, serving property owners and tenants with the same responsiveness and care we'd expect for our own investments.
We built TriStar on a simple principle: owners deserve transparent reporting and honest communication, and tenants deserve a property manager who responds quickly and treats them with respect. That's not just a tagline — it's how we operate every day.
Whether you own a single rental home or a multi-unit portfolio, we handle the details — advertising, screening, leasing, maintenance, inspections, accounting — so you can focus on what matters most to you.
What Sets TriStar Apart
We've built our reputation on doing the basics exceptionally well — and being honest when something isn't.
🔍 Rigorous Tenant Screening
Every applicant goes through credit, background, income verification, and rental history checks. We find tenants who pay on time and take care of your property.
📋 Attorney-Reviewed Leases
Our lease agreements are reviewed by legal counsel and updated regularly to ensure your property is protected under current Colorado landlord-tenant law.
🔧 Trusted Maintenance Network
We've vetted and built relationships with reliable local contractors. Repairs are handled promptly with owner-approved vendors at fair market rates.
💰 Transparent Accounting
Monthly owner statements, year-end 1099s, and direct deposit. No surprise charges. You always know where your money is going.
📸 Professional Marketing
Professional photography, online listings across multiple platforms, and coordinated showings to minimize vacancy and attract quality applicants.
🌐 Online Owner Portal
Access your reports, documents, and property data anytime through your online owner portal — powered by RentManager, a leading property management platform.
Trusted by Owners & Tenants
18+ years of relationships built on transparency and responsiveness.
"I was nervous about hiring a property manager but TriStar made it easy. They're honest, responsive, and genuinely care about protecting your investment."
"The online portal makes everything simple — paying rent, submitting maintenance, seeing my lease. It's the most organized property management experience I've had."
"TriStar has managed my portfolio for years. Their screening process is thorough — I haven't had a bad tenant since switching to them."
Our Service Area
We proudly manage properties across Northern Colorado and the Rocky Mountain Front Range
Managing a property outside these areas? Contact us — we may still be able to help.
Are You a Property Manager?
If you're considering transitioning, selling, or partnering on your portfolio, we'd welcome a confidential conversation.
Explore Portfolio Acquisition